• To submit scores or edit pages, Register/login at the Contributor ChoralWiki • |
Talk:Un flambeau, Jeanette Isabella (Nicolas Saboly)
From ChoralWiki
Merge?
| Help |
|
I support merging under a score page name that lists the composer as anonymous. Just because I arrange Silent Night does not make me it's composer (I wish!). Silent Night (by my name) implies a different song rather than yet another arrangement of a traditional Xmas carol. The score page can then list the individual arranger in the edition notes so searches can still find it. This brings up a broader question--should it also be merged with the score page for [Bring_a_Torch,_Jeanette_Isabella_(Traditional) the English version] of the score? I think yes. The score page should be based on the original language if known, with redirects for the title in the other pages, and indications on the score page about what language the setting is in. What do others think? | |
